Before (end of 2010) (50 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 23 · Other 18 · Liberal Democrats 5 · Labour 4
After (end of 2011) (50 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 25 · Other 16 · Labour 6 · Liberal Democrats 3
Ward results
Castle2 seats · turnout 25.0%
| Janet Jefferson | Independent | 778 ✓ |
| Colin Challen | Labour | 433 ✓ |
| Rosalyn Fox | Conservative | 306 |
| Mark Chamberlain | Conservative | 167 |
Cayton2 seats · turnout 37.8%
| John Blackburn | Conservative | 862 ✓ |
| Simon Green | Independent | 652 ✓ |
| Roberta Swiers | Conservative | 620 |
| James Brace | Labour | 359 |
| Barry Pearson | Liberal Democrats | 175 |
Central2 seats · turnout 22.3%
| David Lawrence Billing | Labour | 350 ✓ |
| Eric Broadbent | Labour | 304 ✓ |
| Malcolm Short | Liberal Democrats | 267 |
| Christine Mark | Independent | 161 |
| Alan Baud | Conservative | 155 |
| Garry Unsworth | Independent | 128 |
| Christopher Philips | Green | 111 |
| Trisha Scott | NF | 56 |
Danby1 seat · turnout 49.4%
| Herbert Tindall | Conservative | 632 ✓ |
| Janet Peake | Labour | 249 |
Derwent Valley2 seats · turnout 39.6%
| David Jeffels | Conservative | 1,072 ✓ |
| Michael Jay-Hanmer | Independent | 817 ✓ |
| Heather Phillips | Conservative | 621 |
| Robert Graham Lockwood | Liberal Democrats | 411 |
Eastfield3 seats · turnout 19.3%
| Brian Simpson | Liberal Democrats | 468 ✓ |
| Geoffrey Evans | Liberal Democrats | 358 ✓ |
| Johannes Zegstroo | Liberal Democrats | 356 ✓ |
| Jo White | Labour | 272 |
| Tracey White | Labour | 260 |
| John Warburton | Labour | 240 |
| Charlotte Gerada | Independent | 107 |
| Gavin Barker | Independent | 97 |
| Michael Kelly | Conservative | 91 |
| Deborah Fox | Conservative | 81 |
Esk Valley2 seats · turnout 41.1%
| Tim Lawn | Conservative | 1,183 ✓ |
| James Preston | Conservative | 928 ✓ |
| Brian Crinion | Independent | 417 |
| Dalton Peake | Labour | 379 |
Falsgrave Park2 seats · turnout 24.9%
| Patricia Marsburg | Independent | 480 ✓ |
| John Ritchie | Labour | 464 ✓ |
| Jennifer Sara Kelly | Conservative | 247 |
| David Hugh Malone | Green | 212 |
| Stuart Swann | Independent | 189 |
| Kevin Riley | Liberal Democrats | 147 |
| Andy Ellis | Independent | 113 |
Filey3 seats · turnout 23.3%
| Mike Cockerill | Independent | 1,281 ✓ |
| Sam Cross | Independent | 1,078 ✓ |
| Colin Haddington | Conservative | 1,015 ✓ |
| Keith Wood | Independent | 396 |
Fylingdales1 seat · turnout 45.4%
| Jane Mortimer | Conservative | 561 ✓ |
| Judith Dennett | Labour | 223 |
Hertford2 seats · turnout 34.7%
| Nicholas Harvey | Green | 1,192 ✓ |
| Godfrey Winston Allanson | Conservative | 902 ✓ |
| Melissa MacDonald | Conservative | 444 |
| Andrew Sharp | Labour | 287 |
Lindhead1 seat · turnout 48.6%
| Andrew Backhouse | Conservative | 699 ✓ |
| Joanne Watson | Labour | 107 |
| Debby McDonald | Independent | 98 |
Mayfield2 seats · turnout 29.7%
| Jane Kenyon | Conservative | 735 ✓ |
| David Chance | Conservative | 602 ✓ |
| Ellie Whitehead | Labour | 569 |
| Tricia Griffin | Green | 310 |
Mulgrave2 seats · turnout 28.7%
| Mary Harland | Conservative | 701 ✓ |
| John Armsby | Independent | 628 ✓ |
| Diane Jeuda | Labour | 287 |
Newby3 seats · turnout 35.9%
| Mick Cooper | Independent | 842 ✓ |
| Brian Walter Joseph Edward Watson | Independent | 841 ✓ |
| Angus Jenkinson | Conservative | 720 ✓ |
| Hazel Lynskey | Conservative | 696 |
| Cecil Ridley | Independent | 676 |
| Susan Backhouse | Conservative | 638 |
| Paul McLean | Labour | 516 |
| Amanda Nunns | Green | 328 |
| Liz Black | Liberal Democrats | 288 |
North Bay2 seats · turnout 26.2%
| Subash Sharma | Labour | 375 ✓ |
| Michael Drummond Moverley Smith | Conservative | 346 ✓ |
| Bonnie Purchon | Independent | 323 |
| Guy William Leslie Smith | Independent | 291 |
| Teddy Sulman | Conservative | 253 |
| Norman Oldham | Green | 144 |
| Billy Black | Liberal Democrats | 109 |
Northstead2 seats · turnout 35.1%
| Peter Popple | Independent | 590 ✓ |
| Norman Murphy | Independent | 445 ✓ |
| Carl Maw | Labour | 429 |
| Angela Micklethwaite-Morris | Conservative | 253 |
| Peter Toolan | Conservative | 251 |
| Kate White | Green | 138 |
| Alix Bartlett-Cook | Liberal Democrats | 94 |
Ramshill2 seats · turnout 28.2%
| Amanda Robinson | Independent | 368 ✓ |
| Nick Brown | Conservative | 350 ✓ |
| Stuart Walker | Conservative | 323 |
| Thomas Creasey | Labour | 301 |
| Svetlana Rodgers | Liberal Democrats | 260 |
| Mark Vesey | Green | 232 |
Scalby, Hackness and Staintondale2 seats · turnout 46.6%
| Derek Bastiman | Conservative | 1,097 ✓ |
| John Flinton | Conservative | 931 ✓ |
| Richard Thompson | Independent | 467 |
| Geoffrey Marsden-Jones | Green | 343 |
| Magnus Johnson | LIB | 335 |
Seamer2 seats · turnout 34.4%
| Helen Mallory | Conservative | 662 ✓ |
| Roxanne Murphy | Independent | 525 ✓ |
| Thomas McGrory | Conservative | 478 |
| David Raine | Independent | 387 |
| Bob Jackman | Liberal Democrats | 294 |
| Michael Cutler | Green | 215 |
Stepney2 seats · turnout 34.1%
| Dilys Cluer | Green | 473 ✓ |
| Lynn Margaret Bastiman | Conservative | 399 ✓ |
| Keith Allen | Independent | 375 |
| Michelle Andrew | Labour | 298 |
| Robert Nicholls | Green | 259 |
| Tony Snow | Independent | 222 |
| Edna Oxley | Labour | 207 |
| Gareth Franks | Liberal Democrats | 138 |
Streonshalh2 seats · turnout 26.3%
| Sandra Turner | Conservative | 394 ✓ |
| Dorothy Clegg | Conservative | 335 ✓ |
| Noreen Wilson | Labour | 302 |
| Simon Parkes | Labour | 277 |
| Ian Havelock | Independent | 200 |
| Ken Graham | Independent | 170 |
| John Dickinson | Independent | 145 |
| Richard Ineson | Independent | 53 |
Weaponness2 seats · turnout 43.9%
| Penny Marsden | Conservative | 774 ✓ |
| Thomas Fox | Conservative | 747 ✓ |
| John Bradley | Independent | 335 |
| Sean Andrew Hunter | Independent | 332 |
| Colin Morgan Barnes | Labour | 260 |
| Judy Deans | Green | 201 |
Whitby West Cliff2 seats · turnout 34.0%
| Joseph Plant | Conservative | 648 ✓ |
| Alf Abbott | Conservative | 512 ✓ |
| Mike Ward | Independent | 321 |
| Geoffrey Wilson | Labour | 289 |
| Gerald Alick James Dennett | Labour | 265 |
| Wynne Jones | Green | 172 |
Woodlands2 seats · turnout 30.1%
| William Chatt | Independent | 522 ✓ |
| Steve Bairstow | Labour | 519 ✓ |
| Philip McDonald | Independent | 312 |
| Josephine O'Leary | Conservative | 241 |
| Peter Southward | Conservative | 209 |
| Sarah Priestley | Green | 114 |
| Andrew Leak | Liberal Democrats | 97 |