Before (end of 2018) (50 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 25 · Labour 13 · Other 10 · Green 2
After (end of 2019) (46 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 16 · Other 14 · Labour 13 · Green 2 · UK Independence Party (UKIP) 1
Ward results
Burniston and Cloughton1 seat
| Andrew Backhouse | Conservative | 356 ✓ |
| Moira Cunningham | Labour | 182 |
| Beverley Kristensen | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 142 |
Castle3 seats
| Janet Jefferson | Independent | 997 ✓ |
| Carl Maw | Labour | 571 ✓ |
| Alex George Bailey | Labour | 568 ✓ |
| David Edmund King | Green | 432 |
| Deirdre Maureen Abbott | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 343 |
| Anthony Gibson | Conservative | 229 |
Cayton2 seats · turnout 28.3%
| Roberta Swiers | Conservative | 601 ✓ |
| Simon Braithwaite Green | Conservative | 559 ✓ |
| Colin Morgan Barnes | Labour | 435 |
Danby and Mulgrave2 seats
| Clive Graham Pearson | Conservative | 718 ✓ |
| Marion Watson | Conservative | 593 ✓ |
| Margaret Jackson | Green | 380 |
| Amanda Barbara Daynes | Labour | 363 |
| Hero Sumner | Independent | 305 |
| Adrian Paul Clarkson | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 246 |
| Sandra Elizabeth Gibson | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 177 |
Derwent Valley and Moor2 seats
| David Jeffels | Conservative | 727 ✓ |
| Heather Phillips | Conservative | 583 ✓ |
| Magnus Laurence Johnson | Green | 445 |
| Robert Graham Lockwood | Liberal Democrats | 339 |
| David Lawrence Billing | Labour | 309 |
| Phil Spruce | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 256 |
| Frank Peter Wright | Independent | 246 |
Eastfield3 seats · turnout 26.2%
| Tony Randerson | Labour | 616 ✓ |
| Joanne Maw | Labour | 452 ✓ |
| Theresa Norton | Labour | 410 ✓ |
| Paul McCann | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 307 |
| John Peter White | Conservative | 202 |
Esk Valley2 seats · turnout 41.1%
| Guy Coulson | Conservative | 813 ✓ |
| Phil Trumper | Conservative | 597 ✓ |
| Peter Alexander Bolton | Labour | 383 |
| Philip Michulitis | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 233 |
Falsgrave and Stepney3 seats
| Neil Francis Robinson | Green | 856 ✓ |
| Will Forbes | Green | 822 ✓ |
| Liz Colling | Labour | 753 ✓ |
| Mark Gordon | Labour | 703 |
| Sally Anne Longden | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 485 |
| Colin Relph | Independent | 466 |
| Sean Andrew Hunter | Independent | 321 |
| Tracey Ann Reeves | Conservative | 252 |
| Richard Ian Thompson | Conservative | 247 |
| Alix Bartlett Cook | Liberal Democrats | 221 |
Filey3 seats · turnout 34.4%
| Sam Cross | Independent | 890 ✓ |
| Mike Cockerill | Independent | 855 ✓ |
| John Bernard Casey | Independent | 789 ✓ |
| Jacqui Houlden-Banks | Independent | 788 |
| Colin Haddington | Independent | 553 |
| Janine Edith Robinson | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 402 |
| Bob Colling | Labour | 332 |
| Terry Parkinson | Conservative | 212 |
| Jane Mortimer | Conservative | 365 ✓ |
| Keith Jeffery | Labour | 209 |
| Stephen Andrew Mayall | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 173 |
Hunmanby2 seats
| Michelle Donohue-Moncrieff | Independent | 972 ✓ |
| Paul Thornton Riley | Independent | 801 ✓ |
| Godfrey Winston Allanson | Conservative | 421 |
| Tom Seston | Conservative | 160 |
| Martin James Whittle | Labour | 158 |
Mayfield2 seats · turnout 30.0%
| Glenn Goodberry | Conservative | 517 ✓ |
| David Chance | Conservative | 416 ✓ |
| Asa Joe Benjamin Jones | Labour | 339 |
| Gerald Alick James Dennett | Labour | 324 |
| Aaron Jones | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 237 |
Newby3 seats · turnout 62.1%
| Eileen Murphy | Independent | 860 ✓ |
| Neil Heritage | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 594 ✓ |
| Subash Sharma | Labour | 591 ✓ |
| Helen Margaret Kindness | Green | 545 |
| Nick Henderson | Independent | 541 |
| Angus Jenkinson | Conservative | 464 |
| Lynn Margaret Bastiman | Conservative | 386 |
Northstead3 seats
| Eric Broadbent | Labour | 624 ✓ |
| Guy William Leslie Smith | Independent | 616 ✓ |
| Joe Atkinson | Independent | 602 ✓ |
| Norman Murphy | Independent | 553 |
| Yvonne Pattison | Labour | 494 |
| Tim Thorne | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 433 |
| Nik Price | Labour | 423 |
| Michael Drummond Moverley Smith | Conservative | 315 |
| Gabrielle Carol Mary Naptali | Green | 313 |
Scalby2 seats
| Hazel Lynskey | Conservative | 516 ✓ |
| Derek Bastiman | Conservative | 495 ✓ |
| Sara Fenander | Green | 424 |
| Mark Vernon Harland | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 371 |
| Tina Davy | Labour | 283 |
Seamer2 seats · turnout 49.1%
| Roxanne Murphy | Independent | 537 ✓ |
| Helen Mallory | Conservative | 390 ✓ |
| Bob Jackman | Liberal Democrats | 338 |
| Zoë Joanna Sinclair | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 324 |
| Colin Challen | Labour | 205 |
| Mark Phillips | Conservative | 193 |
Streonshalh2 seats · turnout 28.1%
| Michael Stonehouse | Labour | 377 ✓ |
| Smitha Campbell | Labour | 368 ✓ |
| Sandra Turner | Conservative | 315 |
| Michael Harrison | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 273 |
| Linda Diane Wild | Conservative | 226 |
Weaponness and Ramshill3 seats
| Jim Grieve | Independent | 828 ✓ |
| Steve Siddons | Labour | 761 ✓ |
| Rich Maw | Labour | 741 ✓ |
| Charlotte Lucinda Bonner | Green | 703 |
| Connor James Young | Labour | 590 |
| Thomas Fox | Conservative | 573 |
| Jennifer Sara Kelly | Conservative | 511 |
| Callam Mark Walsh | Conservative | 447 |
| Stuart Abbott | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 395 |
Whitby West Cliff2 seats · turnout 51.7%
| Sue Tucker | Labour | 323 ✓ |
| Alf Abbott | Conservative | 317 ✓ |
| John David Nock | Conservative | 254 |
| Mike Ward | Independent | 229 |
| Howard Green | Green | 196 |
| Jonathan Harston | Liberal Democrats | 195 |
| Graham Allan Collinson | Independent | 170 |
| Kenneth Hordon | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 154 |
| Lee Francis Derrick | Yorkshire Party | 136 |
Woodlands3 seats · turnout 58.0%
| Phil Kershaw | Independent | 714 ✓ |
| Bill Chatt | Independent | 690 ✓ |
| Peter Popple | Independent | 583 ✓ |
| Andrew Leak | Labour | 437 |
| Richard Moody | Labour | 432 |
| Christopher Phillips | Green | 388 |
| Denise Ann Sangster | Labour | 370 |
| Gareth Edmunds | Conservative | 282 |
| Jack White | Conservative | 203 |
